The Hodgepodge: Dear Close-Minded Independent Country Fans…

Credit: Bananarepublicof9gag Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license

You weren’t expecting this, were you? Well take a seat and listen. As an independent country fan, you’re well aware of the likes of Sturgill Simpson, Jason Isbell, American Aquarium, Wade Bowen and Rosanne Cash. But I’m not addressing all independent country fans. No, I’m addressing the close-minded part of that fan base. Who are the close-minded? The ones I see online everyday refusing to listen to anything offered from mainstream country music. No matter how good that mainstream country music is, they refuse to even give it a chance. Their attitude is: “If it’s mainstream, it’s bad.” In other words, you’re essentially a hipster. You refuse to give something a chance if it’s popular. You have to be different and listen to something that’s obscured. Well let me get this out right up front: you’re hurting country music as much as bro country fans and metro-politan fans are hurting the genre.

Yep. You read that correctly. You’re just as big of a problem as the very people you mock. You’re no different from the Sam Hunt fan who refuses to listen to Sturgill Simpson. You’re the Randy Rogers fan who refuses to listen to Tim McGraw, not because you think McGraw’s music isn’t good, but simply because he’s mainstream. You’re the same person who hated Sturgill Simpson for signing with Atlantic Records, all because you wanted to keep him in your own realm for your own selfish reasons. God forbid Simpson tries to make a better life for himself and his family with this great opportunity. You’re too worried that you can’t see him play in dinky little dive bars anymore for pennies, while Simpson makes pennies from it. See what I mean about you hurting country music?

What prompted me to write this letter is the announcement of “Dress Blues” being featured on Zac Brown Band’s new upcoming album Jekyll + Hyde. That song of course is a Jason Isbell song that was featured on Isbell’s first solo album. It’s a beautiful song with raw emotion about the cold reality of fighting wars. The song is patriotic without the clichés and cheesiness you’ll see in Toby Keith’s ‘Murica pride songs. Simply put this is a song that everyone needs to hear. This discussion about “Dress Blues” started months ago when the Zac Brown Band played this song in a pre-show for the College Football National Championship game. Many started to speculate that this would be covered on the band’s new album and sure enough it is.

Zac Brown Band covering “Dress Blues” does two big things. One it introduces more substance to the mainstream country scene that badly needs it. Second of all it provides more exposure to a phenomenally talented artist like Jason Isbell and at the same time Isbell makes some money off the sales of it. This is a win-win situation. Isbell himself has endorsed Zac Brown Band covering it and shared a link to pre-order it on social media channels. He’s totally on-board with this, but what do a lot of his fans do? They bitch and moan about it. They refuse to even listen to it because Zac Brown Band is mainstream and everything mainstream sucks in their mind. Here’s a small snippets of comments from Isbell’s Facebook post on the news:

Idiot Fans

Now granted there are some people congratulating him on this and leaving nice comments too. Many are saying they listened to Brown’s version and say they prefer Isbell’s version, which is fine. They were open-minded and gave the cover a chance at least. But just look at these comments above. No wonder Isbell never looks at his Facebook page (I know I try to avoid Facebook). His Twitter page doesn’t seem to have these kind of comments, so maybe this is just Facebook people being Facebook people.

Nevertheless it just pisses me off when independent country fans can’t be happy for their favorite artist to be covered in the mainstream or join the mainstream. Choosing to be close-minded on top of this is just infuriating. I listen to all types of music now. I remember when I was close-minded and pretty much just went with whatever was popular. As a result I missed a lot of good music from several genres. I’m a much happier music listener now that I pretty much explore any kind of music that peaks my interest. I have so much music to listen to anymore that I can hardly keep up. It’s a good problem to have. This is all because I opened my mind up to new music. Sure I’ve come across music I hate, but you don’t have to like everything you try.

All I’m saying to you close-minded independent country fans or any close-minded music listener is this: just give it a chance. When you come across something new or a mainstream artist is covering a less known artist’s song, just give it a chance. I won’t kill you to listen. And if you don’t like it? Just move on. And more than anything be happy when the Jason Isbells and Sturgill Simpsons of the world get these great opportunities. Be a real fan, don’t be a hipster douche.

Now if you’ll excuse me I have some music to listen to…

Upcoming/Recent Country Music Releases

  • Kacey Musgraves’ lead single from hear sophomore album, “Biscuits” will officially be released next week. I’ll have a review on it early in the week.
  • Lindi Ortega has released a new single, “Tell It Like It Is,” the lead single off of her new upcoming album. I’m not going to wait until the review to tell you what I think of it either: it’s really good and you need to listen to it. It makes me even more excited to hear this new album from her.
  • George Strait will not only be performing at the 50th ACM Awards, but will be debuting new music. No other information on the new music has been said, other than the fact this is new music from Strait. Considering the situation mainstream country is in right now, we could use some music from Strait. Save us King George!
  • Ronnie Reno will release a new album titled Lessons Learned next Tuesday. For those unfamiliar with Reno, he’s know as “Bluegrass Music’s Youngest Old-Timer.” Ronnie at one point was joined up with the Osborne brothers and the trio won CMA Group of the Year in 1971. After that Merle Haggard hired him away, which allowed him to sing alongside Haggard and his wife Bonnie Owens on songs such as “If We Make It Through December” and “Ramblin’ Fever.” He also wrote Conway Twitty’s #1 hit “Boogie Grass Band.” I’ll have a review on Reno’s new album next week.
  • Allison Moorer will also release a new album next week titled Down To Believing. She’s the former wife of alt-country artist Steve Earle for those unfamiliar with her and this will be her first new album in several years. The lead single she released for the album last November sounded pretty promising, so I’m looking forward to hearing the album.
  • RaeLynn just released a new single called “For A Boy.” This is in fact not off of her terrible Me EP she released back in January. So I guess I should prepare myself to review this one. I’m not going to make Derek review more RaeLynn material because that would be cruel.

Throwback Thursday Song

Sammy Kershaw – “National Working Woman’s Holiday” – Last summer I decided to explore Sammy Kershaw’s catalog of music and my only regret is that I had not done it sooner. To me he doesn’t get near enough credit that he deserves for his great library of music. He kind of got overlooked in the 90s because of the superstardom of Garth Brooks, Shania Twain, Brooks & Dunn, Alan Jackson and George Strait. If you haven’t heard any of his music I highly suggest going back through his catalog (start with his greatest hits album and go from there).

Non-Country Song of the Week

Chris Mann – “Roads” – Back when I was a regular watcher of the show The Voice I wasn’t really impressed by a lot of singers. At least not enough for me to become a fan. There were a few however that did impress me enough to make me a fan. One of those artists was Chris Mann, a classical and opera singer. Now I listen to all genre, but this isn’t usually my cup of tea. But Mann absolutely blew me away with his dynamic vocals. Fun fact: RaeLynn and Gwen Sebastian were also contestants the same season as Mann. He’s only released one album so far and I’m looking forward to his sophomore release.

Tweet of the Week 

How could anyone not like ice cream? Or Sturgill for that matter?

An iTunes Review That Will Make You Face Palm

Another Dumb Hunt Fan

You know I’m just shocked Hunt fans are aware of Hank Williams. And why aren’t they listening to Hank instead?

That’s it for the Hodgepodge this week! Be sure to sound off in the comments! 

12 thoughts on “The Hodgepodge: Dear Close-Minded Independent Country Fans…

  1. Raymond March 12, 2015 / 11:35 am

    Wow I had no idea they were fans like that I mean independent might be better but mainstream has a lot to offer in themselves. Zac Brown Band Carrie Underwood Kacey Musgraves Dierks Bentley Josh Turner Eric Paslay Jon Pardi even good acts like Ashley Monroe Gloriana Gary Allan Maddie & Tae Brothers Osborne David Nail The Band Perry my gosh there’s a lot of good mainstream acts. I mean you still have your Jason’s FGL Luke Bryan Cole Swindell Sam Hunt Raelynn Thomas Rhett Brantley Gilbert Justin Moore Dan + Shay Parmalee and my new least favorite singer ever Michael Ray. Then in Mainstream you have the bland but not offensive Miranda & Blake Eric Church Lady A Little Big Town A Thousand Horses Chris Young Big & Rich Thompson Square Kelsea Ballerini and all the sellouts I will still listen to Eli Young Band Joe Nichols Billy Currington Easton Corbin just not there new stuff. See there’s a lot to like even if some artists are going downhill (Corbin,Nichols,EYB,LBT) but I think Easton will deliver Joe will hopefully go back to his older sound when his new record comes out eventually I would imagine with the bro-country fad fading. I’m done with Eli Young Band. I also think with Pain Killer underperforming in sales I see LBT going back to Tornado and making songs like Your Side of The Bed and Sober and not Day Drinking and Pontoon. Besides that I’m glad that I don’t see those independent fans they’re probably worse than FGL fans at least they don’t act like hipsters some do but not all.

    Moving on Biscuits from Kacey Musgraves heard it once wasn’t bad just wasn’t all that good. I have to confess George Straight has never really impressed me that much honestly he’s a legend but like you guys say Reba’s overrated I think George Straights overrated. Finally Raelynn unless someone pays me a million dollars I’m not listening to that song unless I have to like if it’s on the radio. Point being I’m not listening to it.

    Love Farce The Music so funny honestly however I haven’t heard Sturgill Simpson I know people will be offended but whatever I’m gonna wait till he is on the radio or on my tv for a music video until then I’m not making an opinion.

    Finally that review just no that fan needs to get a reality check. Upbeat is good but you need songs that stop you cold Jake Owen Eric Paslay Carrie Underwood Mickey Guyton LBT Jana Kramer with their new songs. Hopefully things look up.

    Great Hodgepodge I can’t believe how many artists I just talked about. Thank you love your site.


    • Pete Marshall March 12, 2015 / 11:40 pm

      Garth Brooks is more overrated than George Strait that’s my opinion.


      • Raymond March 13, 2015 / 6:38 am

        Both are overrated regardless to me they’ve never impressed me at all.


  2. Scotty J March 12, 2015 / 1:28 pm

    Best Sammy Kershaw song is ‘Politics, Religion And Her’.

    I’m a huge Lindi Ortega fan and I like the new song but at the same time I was mildly underwhelmed. I didn’t absolutely love it the first time I heard it like I did with some of her earlier stuff like ‘The Day I Died’ and of course ‘Tin Star’. But still better than virtually everything out there.

    Allison Moorer’s stuff from very early in her career was really good but she kind of drifted away into who knows what in recent years. She is also the sister of Shelby Lynn (Moorer) so that is one talented family.


  3. bob March 12, 2015 / 3:35 pm

    Mainstream or independent, I don’t care. When I’m deciding whether to buy a song covered by two or more artists, I go with the version that sounds better. It’s music, not reading. For example, as much as I respect the writing of Gretchen Peters, I prefer Trisha Yearwood’s take on the Dreaming Fields. I don’t always go with the mainstream artist. I prefer Georgia Middleman’s version of “I’ll Have What She’s Having” to Reba McEntire’s. Georgia, currently a member of Blue Sky Riders, wrote the song with Jimmy Melton. Most likely I’ll prefer Zac Brown’s “Dress Blues” to Jason Isbell’s. (haven’t heard Zac’s yet.)

    My experience has been that for the most part independent or Americana artists are not strong vocalists. My two worst listening experiences at live shows were by well known Americana singer/songwriters. For one I was lucky to be sitting at the end of the last row so that my wife and I could escape to the lobby without disturbing anyone. The only key this guy sang in was off.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Kevin Davis March 12, 2015 / 3:49 pm

    Yes, I completely agree about this problem in the indie music world.

    I’m glad to see Lindi Ortega is back with new material, shortly after her most recent album! She is a treasure. I saw her live last year, and I was in heaven. She deserves to be our generation’s Dolly Parton or Pam Tillis. Too bad that she was born too late.

    So, George Strait is not retired? The cowboy rides back? I’m happy with that, but I wonder why artists do these elaborate “going away” celebrations, when everybody knows it never lasts. I read somewhere that Strait acknowledged that it was only a semi-retirement — just a downsizing of sorts.


    • Josh Schott March 12, 2015 / 3:53 pm

      Well Strait didn’t retire from making music, just major touring. Got tired of the road basically, but not music. He said he plans to release more albums.


      • Kevin Davis March 12, 2015 / 3:56 pm

        That’s good. Maybe he’ll go strong into his late 70’s like ole Merle and Kris now.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. fromthewordsofbr March 12, 2015 / 6:20 pm

    Hipsters are jerks.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. BrettS March 12, 2015 / 9:05 pm

    I noticed the same thing on Isbell’s Facebook. It’s sad to me that people are so closed-minded. 90% of what I listen to are the no-name independents but I think it’s a damn good song and a great version of it as well. The whole aspect of the article is so very accurate. Like you said its win-win for everyone. I also have a theory that is similar and that’s the ” I only like what I find” theory. Its always seemed to me that some people don’t like to be introduced to new music and they will only like it if they are the ones that comes across it first. I’ve introduced many of people to new music just to have it brushed off and mainly because they weren’t the ones to discover it. Just something I have always thought about.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Pete Marshall March 12, 2015 / 11:37 pm

    I like all country music no matter what it is I don’t like some where country music is going I am a real country music fan. I don’t really care for the songs they play now on today’s radio. There some in the past I’m not to fond of. There some they play now that I really like. I like some of the Indies and Red Dirt/Texas country I like and dislike. Just be a real country fan period.


  8. Pete Marshall March 13, 2015 / 12:02 pm

    anyway Garth Brooks is a major douch of them all.


Comments are closed.