Every week I take a look the Billboard Country Airplay chart from years ago and grade the top 30 songs. Each week will be a different year. It could be 10 years ago, 20 years ago or even further back. The grading format I use each week is every song will receive either a +1, -1 or a 0. These will then be tallied up for an overall score, or pulse of the past top thirty country songs, with the highest possible score being a +30 and the lowest possible score being a -30. How do I determine if a song is rated a +1, -1 or 0? Songs rated between 7 and 10 receive a +1. Songs rated between 5 and 6.5 receive a 0. Songs rated 4.5 or lower receive a -1.
The goal of this exercise is to evaluate the past state of mainstream country music and determine if it was better or worse compared to now. To see the full list of the top 30 country airplay songs for this week, click here. This week I take a look at the top 30 on the Country Airplay Chart from April 13, 2013. After getting a perfect score last week when looking at 1993, we’ll now get to see how much country music regressed over 20 years.
- Hunter Hayes – “Somebody’s Heartbreak” -1 (Too pop sounding)
- Lee Brice – “I Drive Your Truck” +1 (Brice’s best single of his career)
- Lady Antebellum – “Downtown” 0 (I like the sentiment, but it’s overproduced)
- Blake Shelton – “Sure Be Cool If You Did” -1 (It made the bro country mashup, so…)
- Thompson Square – “If I Didn’t Have You” 0 (Pretty forgettable song)
- Chris Young – “I Can Take It From There” 0 (Young doesn’t show enough charisma and energy)
- Miranda Lambert – “Mama’s Broken Heart” -1 (This song is just dumb)
- Kenny Chesney – “Pirate Flag” -1 (This song is even dumber)
- Florida Georgia Line – “Get Your Shine On” -1 (I think this is the song that made the term “sugar shaker” popular)
- Carrie Underwood – “Two Black Cadillacs” 0 (Good production and vocals, but is the violence necessary?)
- George Strait – “Give It All We Got Tonight” +1 (One of his weaker singles, but still good)
- Darius Rucker – “Wagon Wheel” 0 (Just listen to Old Crow Medicine Show’s version)
- Eric Church – “Like Jesus Does” 0 (Too sappy to take seriously)
- Brantley Gilbert – “More Than Miles” 0 (This sounds exactly the same as “You Don’t Know Her Like I Do”)
- Jason Aldean – “1994” -1 (One of Aldean’s worst songs ever)
- Brad Paisley – “Beat This Summer” +1 (A summer tune I can enjoy)
- Tim McGraw & Taylor Swift – “Highway Don’t Care” -1 (This song’s entire arrangement annoys me)
- Dustin Lynch – “She Cranks My Tractor” -1 (Do I really need to explain this one?)
- Blake Shelton – “Boys ‘Round Here” -1 (One of the worst country songs ever)
- The Band Perry – “DONE.” -1 (This song flat-out annoys me)
- Jake Owen – “Anywhere With You” -1 (I’ve heard this song way too many times in my life)
- Zac Brown Band – “Jump Right In” +1 (You either love or hate this song)
- Rascal Flatts – “Changed” 0 (Not bad enough for a -1, not good enough for a +1)
- Gloriana – “Can’t Shake You” 0 (A pretty forgettable song)
- The Henningsens – “American Beautiful” 0 (I forgot about this father-son-daughter trio)
- Kip Moore – “Hey Pretty Girl” -1 (The hook is annoying and Kip sounds bored)
- Jana Kramer – “Whiskey” 0 (A decent song. Nothing more, nothing less)
- Kelly Clarkson & Vince Gill – “Don’t Rush” +1 (This song needed more Vince to be really good)
- Easton Corbin – “All Over The Road” -1 (The start of Easton wasting his talent)
- Brett Eldredge – “Don’t Ya” 0 (Eldredge’s vocals save this song from being terrible)
The Past Pulse of Mainstream Country Music: -8
Pretty terrible list, huh? Amazing how much of a difference there is from 1993 to 2013. Over a 20 year span the pulse went from a perfect +30 to -8, making it a 38 point drop. There are some songs up above that would be strong contenders for the worst country songs ever. If terrible music wasn’t being made, it was usually just safe and neutral music. Hell this time period is even worse than today, which was at -4 this past week. There’s really not any great music, just a few good songs that save this chart from being a total wash. Of course this is right before bro country would become huge.
Personally I remember being a pretty disinterested country music fan at this time. My frustration started in late 2012 and at this point I was drifting away from the genre. I went about five months in 2013 without turning on country radio. Zac Brown Band and Brad Paisley were the only country music I would listen to in my music library. I really got into rap music. When I returned and saw it had gotten even worse, that was when I began my search for country music beyond the mainstream and started the path to me eventually creating this site.
As is now customary, fire away with your comments and questions about this week’s past pulse.