Album Review – Mudcrutch’s ‘2’

Before there was The Heartbreakers, Tom Petty had Mudcrutch, a southern rock/alt country band. Mudcrutch initially formed in 1970, but after fives year with no musical traction, the band split and Petty went on to do great things with The Heartbreakers. Over the last eight years though, Tom Petty has brought Mudcrutch back together for some short tours and a few album releases, including released in May. As mainstream country grew in popularity due to bro-country, Tom Petty turned heads with his comments on the music, calling it “bad rock with a fiddle.” While Mudcrutch falls into Americana with 2 rising up the Americana Airplay Chart, the album has a couple good offerings of country and rockabilly songs mixed in with Petty’s style of rock.

The album opens with a harmonica playing over a simple drum beat and guitar strum on “Trailer.” The song details a man who, upon graduating high-school, got himself a mobile home to start his own life with the girl he loves. “Trailer” highlights the ups and downs of their life together. “Dreams of Flying” sounds like a vintage Tom Petty rock song, with longer guitar solos accompanied by a faint organ sound. The lyrics hint at the attraction of the rock and roll lifestyle, with an itch to get out and explore the world and fly.

Mudcrutch slows it down with love song “Beautiful Blue.” The spacey, rock ballad production feature piano and organ keys along with another extended solo in the middle of the song, and a nice piano solo toward the song’s end. “Beautiful Blue” certainly has a callback sound to 70s classic rock. “Beautiful World” touches on love again, in a more anthemic, mid-tempo rock song. The song touches on mystery and uncertainties in life, but the love shared between the man and woman in the song make those uncertainties worth it. “I Forgive It All” takes a different approach to dealing with life’s curveballs. The acoustic ballad finds the narrator down on his luck with little money, but he keeps pushing along and forgiving the downs of life.

“The Other Side of the Mountain” takes a turn into country music with a prominent banjo setting the beat in the production. The “mountain” in the song separates two lovers who long to be with one another, but can’t figure out how to navigate around the mountain. “Hope” is another song with a classic rock production. The guitar lick in the middle of the song actually reminds me a bit of Eric Clapton and Cream’s “White Room.” The song is a thank you to a friend, or even a prayer to a religious figure, for providing hope and a more joyous outlook in life.

The rockabilly side of Mudcrutch comes out with “Welcome to Hell.” The piano beat and simple, repetitive drum beats make the song sound like a remastered 50s hit, a sound that suits the band well. “Welcome to Hell” details the fall of a relationship and marriage. The emotional nature of the lyrics is lost in contrast to the upbeat production, but the song works well as it’s produced. Failed relationships and the country sound continue in “Save Your Water.” The woman of this relationship is playing games, and he’s tired of playing along, so he finally burns bridges and breaks the ties. “Save Your Water” is ultimately forgettable.

The quick southern rock tune “Victim of Circumstance” is an upbeat driving song. In this relationship, the man is taking a long journey back to California, hoping his woman will welcome him with one more chance. Mudcrutch closes out 2 with the six-minute “Hungry No More.” The song tells the story of a man who’s been beaten down by life, yet he’s still determined to fight back and make the best out of the situation. “Hungry No More” is a slow burning track with a mid-tempo beat, but the songs packs a bunch in the final two minutes with a roaring guitar solo.

Mudcrutch’s second album showcases a good musical variety for Tom Petty and his bandmates. Mike Campbell (guitarist) and Benmont Tench (keyboards) are also members of The Heartbreakers. Drummer Randall Marsh and singer/guitarist Tom Leadon round out Mudcrutch. The five-piece band are experienced musicians and producers, and that experience helps this album work. The balance between country and rock and the way the two genres blend help shine. It’s the sort of album you come to expect from a group of musicians at this point in their career: solid, well-produced songs.

Grade: 8/10